I am more inclined to believe the Greeks were the first to come up with democracy but that the Italians were good at copying ideas in art, religion and architecture from the Greeks.
Human nature is inclined to copy and adapt as its own, earlier developments in many fields, from music to religion.
The democracy in Greece was not without it's critics, however, and a leading Athenian philosopher said poor democracy was just as bad as poor rule by other forms.
It was against the increasingly harsh rule of Peisistratus's eldest son that Cleisthenes (a progressive aristocrat) championed a radical political reform movement, laid out 100 years earlier, 600BC, by Solon (a poet and a wise statesman, but not a democrat). He did not believe in people-power as such.
But it was Solon's constitutional reform package that laid the basis on which democracy could be pioneered almost 100 years later, which in the early 500's BC ushered in the Athenian democratic constitution.
Even then a birth criterion of double descent - from an Athenian mother as well as father - was strictly insisted upon. Women, even Athenian women, were totally excluded - this was a men's club. Foreigners, especially unfree slave foreigners, were excluded formally and rigorously. The citizen body was a closed political elite.
Interesting to knock such ideas about, MJ and I have no idea where the digital radio went to but perhaps I should stop here as otherwise Geoff will have to create a new thread and he probably has enough on his hands already!
